78 Comments

If non-whitemen have a higher rate of novelty overall, but whitemen have a higher rate of *impactful* novelty, doesn't that rather suggest that non-whitemen generate more ideas that are useless and unworkable?

Expand full comment

I think that trying to parse the logic of shit is a poor use of time, and so I've taken up day-drinking.

Expand full comment

I lap up 74 bowls of GET DOWN every day.

Expand full comment

Ah, but you see... because the novel ideas are useless and unworkable, it just proves structural racism!

It's all whitey's fault, of course.

Expand full comment

That's what I took from it.

Expand full comment

Dr. Lysenko . . . Dr. Trofim Lysenko . . . please call your office.

Expand full comment

I’m a professional engineer. All this shit has already completely infested my professional regulatory body and every engineering firm. Remember what Pete Bootyjudge (sp?...ah who cares!) said: roads are racist.

It’s not just racist roads. Photons and electrons are racist. Moments of inertia are racist. The conservation of momentum is sexist. And thermodynamics is transphobic. None of this can be made right unless far more of my professional peers are brown skinned uterus owning people-kinds.

Expand full comment

Wasn’t it wokeness that built that bridge that collapsed in Florida?

Expand full comment

How DARE you!?!?! I AM TRIGGERED.

Expand full comment

I can't speak for all STEM jobs, but I want my surgeons and pilots to be big on "novelty".

Expand full comment

"I've just thought of the most wonderfully creative thing to do to your kidneys!"

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Sep 30, 2022
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

LIVER LET LIVE!

Expand full comment

Yeah, I mean checklists, standard procedures and following ATC guidance is just so oppressive. We need truly intersectional pilots and structural freedom in our flight operations.

Expand full comment

DEFUND DC, today.

Expand full comment

Yeah, it is our tax dollars. Easy to forget we pay for this garbage.

Expand full comment

Hmmm. Maybe we could stop PAYING...

Expand full comment

Right up there with this bullshit. Observing whiteness in introductory physics: A case study.

https://journals.aps.org/prper/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.18.010119

I can't believe people get grants for sh*t like this.

Expand full comment

That was painful.

Expand full comment

Do you fink if I send them a box of dog logs, they will send me a check?

Expand full comment

It's called "the long march through the institutions". Weaponizing the Peter Principle is just for starters.

Expand full comment

“Hey, I just discovered a cure for this awful disease”.

“Sir, you’re white. Please go away”

Expand full comment

Now the "alphabet" people have invaded science - not that NSF funding was not political before - it was. The upshot of this escalation of wokeness is that only conformists to this notion of BIPOC will want to enter the academic research world which in turn will exponentially expand that concept to keep sane people out. Try to propose a study of the beneficial effects of carbon dioxide on health and growth and see if you can get funded. Are tall plants discriminating against small plants and are fires preferring trees with less water? Chris - I don't know where this ends - but it's not in a good place. I refused two academic appointments in teaching science in the 70s because funding was biased toward favorite projects of the people with connections to the funders. Thank for highlighting this.

Expand full comment

perhaps "their novel contributions are discounted” because novelty alone doesn't make a piece of work relevant or important

Expand full comment

"Gravity is caused by orange cheese." A novel concept in physics!

Expand full comment

I’ve got a novel idea… lead airplanes

Expand full comment

you can't use the color "orange" anymore because of it's association with a certain ex (and possibly future) president

Expand full comment

How DARE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I am TRIGGERED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Expand full comment

How DARE you!?!?!?! I am TRIGGERED!!!!!!

Expand full comment

The paper seemed to hint at some kind of bigotry was why the ideas were discounted. Which I doubt.

Expand full comment

of course. anything that doesn't go in your favor MUST be due to racism

Expand full comment

I can’t think of any comment that is printable.

Expand full comment

I know that feeling.

Expand full comment

They put the jedi in BAJEDI. The Force Be With You, Chris!

Expand full comment

Jedi dignifies it too much. In my head, it's pronounced "bajeddy" and rhymes with spaghetti. This allows such constructs as:

- BAJEDIOs

- Flying BAJEDI Monster

- Mom's BAJEDI

- Throwing the policy at the wall and hoping something sticks

Expand full comment

Soon US academia will be left to stew in its own juices, as bright foreigners learn to stay away.

Expand full comment

Two alternate acronyms:

IDEA BJ

JAB DIE

Both seem oddly appropriate.

Expand full comment

It has taken me a few days to comment after reading this, because my mind cannot process that anyone at NSF actually and unironically deployed the ridiculous acronym “BAJEDI.” It sounds vaguely like it has something to do with Star Wars and baccalaureates to me. Absurd.

Call the code already: science as we once knew it is dead. What this thing is in its place, I don’t ever want to know.

Expand full comment

GIGO

Expand full comment