Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kevan Hudson's avatar

The online left is literally a textbook example of catastrophizing. I am an old school leftist, most likely a Nazi to many modern leftists, and whether long time friends on Facebook or Substackers I follow I am continually amazed at how Trump lives rent free in all their minds. You would think we were dinosaurs facing an asteroid level extinction. Anyways, time for me to go back to making my fascist pamphlets about protecting local rivers.

Expand full comment
jjinUK64's avatar

The latest iteration of the 'it isn't happening' > 'ok it's happening, but not much' > 'ok it's happening, and that's a good thing!' cycle:

> The deep state is not real, you paranoid dummy!

> Ok it is real, but it's good people, doing good work!

> Ok they suck and do terrible stuff, but don't try to reform or reduce it, that would be fascism!

We see this all over the centre and soft left (inc outlets like Free Press) with DEI too. The latest thing is "Well, yes DEI sucks and is pernicious and quite harmful... but don't try to remove it, that would be disruptive and bad!".

I don't know how you make progress with a large contingent of people who hold this viewpoint. They'll admit everything is broken, but scream and gnash their teeth over any attempts to fix it too. I'm starting to think we'll just have to ignore them and move civilisation forward without them, hope they catch up.

I've come to think of it like the toddler who refuses to eat the dinner and sits at the table with their arms crossed, kicking their feet under the table in a little tantrum. They're still part of the family so we love them, but the behaviour is not reasonable. Yet often we find it's better to leave them there and simply ignore them — keep talking and eating and laughing, and act like the tantrum at the end of the table is not happening. They eventually realise everyone is enjoying a nice dinner without them, and they'll fold and just start eating the dinner with the rest of the family.

And then, for the sake of harmony, we pretend that tantrum didn't happen and we just enjoy dinner. Maybe that's what will have to happen here?

Expand full comment
227 more comments...

No posts